In 1362 Oxfordshire, Emma Denny's All the Painted Stars delivers a captivating queer historical romance. Lily Barden, disguised as a knight, enters a dangerous tournament to rescue her best friend, Johanna, from a forced marriage. Their escape leads them to unexpected freedom and a blossoming romance amidst idyllic countryside. This friends-to-lovers story, praised for its tenderness and slow burn, explores the complexities of love and choice in a challenging era. With echoes of Freya Marske and Alexis Hall, All the Painted Stars is a delightful read for fans of historical romance, promising thrilling adventure and heartwarming connection. Prepare to be swept away by Lily and Johanna's journey.
Review All the Painted Stars
All the Painted Stars completely charmed me. From the initial premise – a woman disguising herself as a knight to rescue her best friend from an unwanted marriage – I was hooked. Emma Denny masterfully crafts a world that feels both historically grounded and intensely romantic, a delicate balance that’s not easy to achieve. The descriptions of 14th-century Oxfordshire are vivid and evocative, transporting you to the bustling tournament grounds and the peaceful serenity of the lakeside brewery. The author’s skill lies not just in setting the scene, but in breathing life into her characters.
Lily and Jo are absolute treasures. Lily’s impulsive bravery and fierce loyalty are captivating, her transformation into a knight a delightful blend of humor and heart. Jo, while initially appearing more reserved, possesses a quiet strength that perfectly complements Lily’s fiery spirit. Their relationship is the heart of the story, a slow-burn romance that feels authentic and deeply satisfying. The chemistry between them crackles on the page, and their journey, from best friends to lovers, is both heartwarming and poignant. It’s not just a whirlwind romance; it's a careful exploration of love's sacrifices and the challenges of making choices in the face of societal expectations.
While the tournament serves as a thrilling backdrop to their story, I particularly loved the quieter moments – the stolen glances, the shared laughter, the intimate conversations amongst the blackberry bushes. These moments of intimacy are what truly cemented the connection between Lily and Jo for me. These scenes aren't just romantic; they reveal the depth of their understanding, their shared vulnerabilities, and the enduring strength of their bond. Even the supporting characters are richly drawn, each with their own purpose and personality; Mabel, the brewster, quickly became a personal favorite, a strong and independent woman who offers refuge and wisdom.
The pacing, while deliberate, felt appropriate for the genre and allowed for a deeper connection with the characters. The book does utilize some well-loved tropes, but Denny avoids cliché by infusing them with a fresh perspective. The "third act breakup," though predictable, felt earned within the context of the narrative and ultimately strengthened the emotional resonance of the story's resolution. The level of intimacy is tastefully handled, adding to the romance without overshadowing the character development and plot progression.
Overall, All the Painted Stars is a triumph. It's a story that stayed with me long after I finished reading, a testament to Denny’s talent for storytelling and character creation. The blend of historical detail, captivating romance, and compelling characters makes this a five-star read for me. It's the kind of book that leaves you feeling warm and content, eager to return to its pages again and again. If you enjoy historical romances with strong female leads, witty banter, and a healthy dose of heartwarming romance, then this book is an absolute must-read.
Information
- Dimensions: 5.08 x 0.83 x 7.8 inches
- Language: English
- Print length: 336
- Publication date: 2024
- Publisher: HQ